0
Finest Known
Order Today: 888-900-9948 Login
  • Coins For Sale
    • Small Denomination
      • Copper Type Coins
      • Nickel Type Coins
      • Three Cent Silver
    • Early Coinage
      • Early American Silver
      • Early American Gold
      • American Colonials
      • Ancient Greek Coins
      • Ancient Roman Coins
    • Silver Coinage
      • Seated Liberty Silver
      • Silver Barber Coins
      • 1916 Silver Liberties
      • Morgan Silver Dollars
      • Peace Dollars
    • Gold Coinage
      • Liberty Head Gold
      • Indian Princess Gold
      • Indian Gold Coins
      • Gold Double Eagles
    • Other
      • Territorials Items
      • Commemoratives
      • Treasure
      • Utah Goldbacks
      • Nevada Goldbacks
      • Other
  • Shop By Category
    • Blank
      • $20 Double Eagle
      • $10 Gold Eagle
      • $5 Half Eagle
      • $1, $2.50 & $3 Gold
      • Silver Dollars
      • Other Silver
      • Cents-Nickels
    • Blank
      • Colonial
      • Territorial
      • Commemoratives
      • Ship Of Gold
      • Rare Ingots
      • Treasure
      • Civil War Money
    • Blank
      • Key Date Rarities
      • Finest Known
      • Top-100 Greatest
      • Proof Grade
      • Proof-Like
      • CAC Sticker
      • VAM Dollars
    • Blank
      • Best Values
      • Featured Items
      • Internet Specials
  • Top-10 to Buy Now
    • Blank
      • Buy Key Date Rare Coins
      • Buy Type I $20 Liberties
      • Buy Carson City Silver Dollars
      • Buy GSA Holder Silver Dollars
      • Buy SS Central America Coins
    • Blank
      • Buy Finest Known Specimens
      • Buy $2.50 Quarter Eagle Indians
      • Buy Private and Territorial Issues
      • Buy Walking Liberty Half Dollars
      • Buy Rare Gold Monetary Ingots
  • How To Purchase Best
    • Blank
      • 14 Reasons to Put Money in Money
      • Why Quality Coins over Quantity
      • Why Collect Morgan Silver Dollar
      • Why Purchase Indian Head Gold
      • 3 Most Beautiful Silver Liberties
    • Blank
      • Buy Early U.S. Gold Coinage
      • Why Purchase Proof Coins
      • Buy Top-100 Greatest US Rare Coins
      • Civil War Money Introductory Sets
      • Books, Catalogs and Literature
  • TV Specials
    • $49 Morgan Silver Dollar Offer
    • Special 20+1 Silver Dollars
    • Special 50+1 Silver Dollars
  • Latest News
  • 0
Order Today: 888-900-9948
Close
  • Coins For Sale
    • Small Denomination
      • Copper Type Coins
      • Nickel Type Coins
      • Three Cent Silver
    • Early Coinage
      • Early American Silver
      • Early American Gold
      • American Colonials
      • Ancient Greek Coins
      • Ancient Roman Coins
    • Silver Coinage
      • Seated Liberty Silver
      • Silver Barber Coins
      • 1916 Silver Liberties
      • Morgan Silver Dollars
      • Peace Dollars
    • Gold Coinage
      • Liberty Head Gold
      • Indian Princess Gold
      • Indian Gold Coins
      • Gold Double Eagles
    • Other
      • Territorials Items
      • Commemoratives
      • Treasure
      • Utah Goldbacks
      • Nevada Goldbacks
      • Other
  • Shop By Category
    • Blank
      • $20 Double Eagle
      • $10 Gold Eagle
      • $5 Half Eagle
      • $1, $2.50 & $3 Gold
      • Silver Dollars
      • Other Silver
      • Cents-Nickels
    • Blank
      • Colonial
      • Territorial
      • Commemoratives
      • Ship Of Gold
      • Rare Ingots
      • Treasure
      • Civil War Money
    • Blank
      • Key Date Rarities
      • Finest Known
      • Top-100 Greatest
      • Proof Grade
      • Proof-Like
      • CAC Sticker
      • VAM Dollars
    • Blank
      • Best Values
      • Featured Items
      • Internet Specials
  • Top-10 to Buy Now
    • Blank
      • Buy Key Date Rare Coins
      • Buy Type I $20 Liberties
      • Buy Carson City Silver Dollars
      • Buy GSA Holder Silver Dollars
      • Buy SS Central America Coins
    • Blank
      • Buy Finest Known Specimens
      • Buy $2.50 Quarter Eagle Indians
      • Buy Private and Territorial Issues
      • Buy Walking Liberty Half Dollars
      • Buy Rare Gold Monetary Ingots
  • How To Purchase Best
    • Blank
      • 14 Reasons to Put Money in Money
      • Why Quality Coins over Quantity
      • Why Collect Morgan Silver Dollar
      • Why Purchase Indian Head Gold
      • 3 Most Beautiful Silver Liberties
    • Blank
      • Buy Early U.S. Gold Coinage
      • Why Purchase Proof Coins
      • Buy Top-100 Greatest US Rare Coins
      • Civil War Money Introductory Sets
      • Books, Catalogs and Literature
  • TV Specials
    • $49 Morgan Silver Dollar Offer
    • Special 20+1 Silver Dollars
    • Special 50+1 Silver Dollars
  • Latest News
  • Account Login

1809/8 Capped Bust $5 NGC MS64

Rare Coin News

December 28, 2011 Rare Coin News Monaco Rare Coins

A pristine and original specimen of this controversial overdate. Harry Bass owned two examples of variety and seemed to question the status of the overdate being a 9 struck a previous 8. However, it is highly recognized and popular variety none the less. It is referred to as the “scarcest” date of this variety in a number early gold encyclopedias.

1809/8 Capped Bust $5 NGC MS64

As noted above, Bass doubted the overdate status of this variety, but traditionally it has been considered one. Tradition often wins over reality and, as noted, this author and many notable others agree with Bass. There is something under the 9, but whether it is an 8 or remnants of an erroneously punched 9 is uncertain.

One interesting feature that has received scant attention is the large 9 punch employed on this die. It is much larger than the other digits. The partial numeral under the 9 does not seem to match the curve of an 8 or this 9. As with many other early gold issues, we sometimes have to draw the best conclusion that we can from the existing specimens. This work has kept the traditional moniker for this date of 1809/8/

Whether an overdate or not, this is a popular date and variety and one that draws a tremendous attention from collectors. As with many controversial issues in numismatics, this can prove to be a driving factor in demand.

The population of this coin in MS64 is listed as 61, but certainly there are many resubmissions in this number as is probably the case with the 13 MS65 examples. To date the finest is a lone MS66 by PCGS. Only 21 appearances are listed of MS64s and 5 MS65s in the auction record since 1990.

Two MS64s have appeared in 2011 and have an average priced realized of $62,006. The last MS65 to appear was in May 2010 and realized $77.050.

These prices realized provide ample confirmation that the specimen offered here at only $60,000 is an exceptional value.


  • Newsletter
  • Be Among the First to Know of Breaking News and Special Offers on Amazing Rare Coins.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

For a confidential, personal consultation on buying or selling specific rare coins, call Monaco Rare Coins today: 888-900-9948

Free Civil War Shipwreck Treasure Catalog
Sell Your Coins to Monaco Rare Coins

Archives by Year

  • 2018 (3)
  • 2017 (2)
  • 2016 (9)
  • 2015 (10)
  • 2014 (5)
  • 2013 (4)
  • 2012 (12)
  • 2011 (12)
  • 2010 (7)
  • 2009 (13)
  • 2008 (8)
  • 2007 (3)
  • 2006 (5)
  • 2005 (10)
  • 2004 (8)
  • 2003 (1)
  • 2002 (6)
  • 2001 (6)
  • 2000 (4)
  • 1999 (7)
  • 1998 (259)
  • Back to Blog
  • Prev
  • Next
FOR MORE INFORMATION
888-900-9948
Contact Us
Sell Your Coins
Payment Methods
About Monaco
Terms of Sale
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
© 2021 Monaco Rare Coins
All Rights Reserved.
Facebook